Backpacking:
-Complete freedom/flexibility: the most obvious positive feature is that you can do what you want, when you want... as long as its not taking pictures of certain communist buildings :S ops
-Meet more people: I suppose this could be a pro or con depending on if you're introverted or extroverted and the quality of people you're meeting. My general experience has been pretty good meeting other backpackers, probably because you have similar tastes and instantly have a topic of common interest... travel!
-Go places tours don't go: you can get a more “real” feel for the place you're visiting, tours tend to sugar coat the place you're visitng, which is a pro or con depending on what you're looking to get out of your trip.
-Quality of vacation doesn't relying on the quality of the tour: this is a big one, since the tour company and other travellers on the tour can make or break your vacation, so you're taking a big gamble.
-Way cheaper: generally...
-Working holiday: although backpacking is LOADS of fun, its certainly not a relaxing vacation (at least when I did it) because you're running from place to place trying to soak everything in. I needed a few days to recuperate when I got home haha.
Tours:
-Leave your brain at home: best feature (in my opinion) of going on a tour is that you can relax when it comes to getting from point A to point B, meals, itinerary etc because someone else is doing it all for you, so you can kick back and relax... without that useless muscle upstairs.
-Make good friends: since you're thrown together with the same people for x number of days, you get to know the people you're on the tour with better than if you had run into them in a hostel or on a train.
-Safety: depending on the location, this can be a BIG thing, or not even come into your decision making process.
-Cost: tours can be done pretty inexpensively if you're willing to hunt around, but obviously at the end of the day you're going to pay a premium for leaving your brain at home.
-Loss of freedom: you have to do what's on the itinerary, granted there are many options for tours so you can pick the one that suits you best, and there is lots of free time built in, but the tour guide does need to keep a tab on you so that means no kayaking out of site, even if there is a cool cave just beyond reach :(
Conclusion? Its time for me to say those 3 little words my family have been waiting for me to say, “I was wrong”. Yes you heard (or erm read) it here first, 'I was wrong', scheduled tours can be very enjoyable as well, and I would be all for going on a tour with my family some day instead of backpacking (this is a huge debate in the Smith house when we talk about family vacations) granted that we weigh the pros and cons of each...





